Should You Pay Off Your Mortgage Early or Invest to Make More Money

The big key to Growing your rental property business is to use leverage and OPM which is other people's money. The question though is if you should pay off your mortgage or invest your money? This is a delema that I will help you figure what is the right path for you.

I personally kept reinvesting my money back into more real estate rental properties. After 7 years, I had 30 rental properties making me $15,000 a month in passive income. This is something anyone can do.

So, Should you pay off your mortgage or invest your money? You should not pay off your mortgage but rather invest in more real estate that makes you money in passive income.

Now you may get to the point where you start to ask yourself whether or not you should pay off some of the mortgages that you currently have on all your properties.

The answer depends on a number of factors and comes with each person's own situation.

Table of Contents Show

Listen to the Episode On Should You Pay Off Your Mortgage Or Invest

In today’s session, we are going to talk all about the mortgages you have on your rental properties and whether or not you should pay them off sooner by paying extra or with a lump sum of cash.

Good Debt vs. Bad Debt

Good debt puts money in your pocket every single month and bad debt takes money out of your pocket every single month.

Remember, mortgages you have on rental properties are helping you make money every single month.

When I first started, I had many mortgages. Those mortgages were being paid by my tenants every month and I was making at least $250 a month on every single one.

FREE Making Money with Real Estate Investing Course

Get the real estate investing course for FREE and Subscribe to the MPI Newsletter with loads of investing tips, advice, and advanced strategies for investing in real estate.


Should You Pay Off the Mortgage On Your Properties?

My wife and I are now at the point where we had maybe four or five different mortgages on properties that we have been able to pay off in cash.

We do have three mortgages left on thirty plus properties, but that isn’t bad. We have a lot of passive income coming in, and we utilized that cash to pay off the debt.

Each investor has a different situation. There are many scenarios where it makes sense to pay of the mortgages and many where it does not, especially if it allows you to keep investing.

Here are the things you should think through to help you answer your questions…

Are You Still Building Your Business?

When I first got started, I put down $17,000 cash on a property. After about six or eight months, I refinanced the property and took the money out of it and bought another property with that money.

After another six months, I refinanced the second property and used that money to buy a third and fourth. I did this over and over again, because I like to recycle my money.

I bought a $150,000 property in Texas, and after I fixed it up and had it rented, I pulled that money out and bought four more properties in Akron, Ohio.

The beautiful thing is that my tenants are paying off the mortgages on each property. I am just recycling the money over and over again.

I love having leverage and debt on my properties, because they help me build my business bigger, stronger, and faster. On top of that, my tenants are paying off my mortgages!

They are paying off all of the fees and expenses.

Let’s say you buy a house for $100,000 and you put 3.5 percent down on an FHA loan, which is $3,500. After you live in it for a year and you get a tenant in there to live in it for 15, 20, or 30 years, the tenant pays the rest of the $96,500!

This would normally come out of your pocket, plus the interest, which is roughly another $100,000. It is brilliant to be able to use other people’s money!

When I was building my business, before I quit my job, I wanted to make sure that all of the money got reinvested back into the business.

Have You Quit Your Job?

Is your business big enough for you to quit your job and live a dream life?

If you haven’t already quit your job, maybe think about not paying off those mortgages and saving your cash so you can buy more properties and make more passive income.

It may be worth not putting extra money toward the mortgages so you can buy another property and make another $250 a month.

If you’ve already quit your job and you don’t need that money, and you aren’t looking at continuing to build your business, look at possibly paying off some of those notes.

What Is The Opportunity Cost Of Your Money?

Opportunity cost basically says, if you use your money to pay off a mortgage, that money could have been used to buy another property.

The opportunity cost is all of the income you could have made from another property that you could have bought with that money.

If you pay off a mortgage, you are decreasing the amount of expenses, but what if instead of paying it off, you bought another property with that money, and that other property brought in another $250?

What other opportunities are out there for your money, so you can make more money.

What Are The Other Investment Opportunities?

Let’s say you have $30,000 in cash and you want to pay off one note that has a balance of $28,000. You could do that, but what other investment opportunities are out there?

If there is a property where you could make $100 in passive income a month, it might be better to just use the $30,000 to pay off your mortgage.

However, what if you found a great opportunity that would bring you $300 a month in passive income?

That might be worthwhile.

You need to look at your other investment opportunities.

Right now, the way the market and the economy is going, it is really a seller’s market. People are getting top dollar for properties, but I don’t pay top dollar when I buy —I get top dollar when I sell.

Currently, I am not seeing many investments I want to buy, so I am staying on the sidelines waiting for opportunities to come up.

At the beginning of this year, in February, I bought three single-family homes and a duplex off an investor. I bought, because it was a good deal.

I am not out there forcing deals, I am waiting for opportunities to come.

I can do this, because I’ve already quit my job and I am not continuing to build my business right now, because of how high the market is and how expensive everything is for real estate.

What Is Your Risk And Debt Tolerance?

How well can you tolerate risk and debt on each property? My wife is much less gung ho than I am. I am a doer, but she is more of somebody who wants to stay grounded.

From the very beginning, she was very conscious of making sure we were not over extending ourselves and getting way out ahead.

She has helped me stay grounded. Her risk tolerance is much lower than mine. If there was a risk tolerance scale, I would be at an eight or nine and she would be at a one or two.

I look at both of our strengths and weaknesses and she helps me look at the risks in a negative light and I help her look at the risks in a positive light and we work together.

If you have too much debt and get over leveraged, banks might not loan to you. If you find a fantastic deal where you will be making $600 a month in passive income, you might not be able to buy it.

Make sure you understand the big picture of how many mortgages you can have.

Federal law says the maximum is ten mortgages in your personal name, however banks don’t like to lend more than four.

Of course, you could have ten in your name and ten in your spouse’s name.

What Is The Return On Investment For Your Money?

How much can you get for the money you have saved or invested in a stock or mutual fund?

I don’t recommend investing in stocks or mutual funds, but instead I recommend investing in real estate properties.

I currently keep my money in a CapitalOne 360 money market account, and you will get $25, if you sign up using this link. This account pays me 1.7 percent every single month.

That’s great, but why hold the money for 1.7 percent interest, when I can pay off a mortgage that is at 6 percent?

That would save me almost 4.5 percent every month! What if you used the same money and bought a rental property that would bring in $250 or $300 a month?

That’s where you are actually making more money and the tenant is paying off the debt.

making money with rental properties

Making Money with Rental Properties FREE Investing Course

Get it FREE and Subscribe to the MPI Newsletter with loads of investing tips, advice, and advanced strategies for investing in real estate.


Do You Need The Cash Flow To Live Every Month?

Let’s say you are paying an extra $500 a month to pay off a note on a property.

If you pay off that note, that’s $500 a month that you are not spending anymore, which increases the amount of money that is in your pocket every single month.

What Are The Interest Rates On Your Current Mortgages?

If you have a note for $100,000 at three percent interest, you are better off keeping that one, because if you pay it off and buy another property at four or five percent interest you are just wasting your money.

What Are The Interest Rates Going To Be Like In The Future?

What are the interest rates doing? Are they going up? If so, you are better off keeping your low-interest rate loans.

Do You Have An Emergency Fund Saved Up For Future Expenses?

As investors, we need to have emergency funds. This also acts as a capital account where any money goes in and out, but the balance must be positive.

If a furnace goes out, it could cost $5,000.

If you don’t have that much in your account, then you will need to pay for it with a credit card and that is not something you want to do. You need an emergency account for when bad things happen.

With my car, I had to pay $2,500 to fix my radiator. I had the money saved in an emergency fund and I didn’t need to put that on a credit card and incur bad debt.

How Many Mortgages Do You Have In Your Name?

If you need to pay off a mortgage to free up another slot, you may need to do that. Remember, you are only allowed to have ten mortgages in your name.

Look at your current notes and what you have and make sure you can continue to grow your business with the mortgages that you have.

Do You Need to Get Another Mortgage in the Future?

In my book, Successfully Unemployed, I documented how I quit my job and all of the lessons I learned. One thing I learned is that I couldn’t quit my job until I got my last mortgage.

I was getting a blanket loan over four different properties, to pull out the money to buy more properties. Even though it was my goal I didn't want to quit my job, because banks don’t like when you quit your job in the middle of the loan process.

I stayed at my job a little longer, even though I didn’t want to, because I knew it would be much harder to get mortgages after I quit.

When you are thinking about paying off your mortgages on your rental properties, keep all of these things in mind. After I quit my job, I paid off three or four mortgages, because I could.

Now I am waiting on the sidelines for the deals to come to me when the market corrects itself. There is no reason prices are back up to the amount they were before the market crashed in 2008.

Remember back then when there was a huge run up of prices and then a huge crash?

Well, prices are right back up to where they were then. In my opinion there is no reason for that, other than the same reason they were up back then.

I am being careful, because I don’t want to buy bad deals. There are still good deals out there, but you need to be careful.


If you want to start investing in real estate, or if you are even curious about it, I have a free course for you.

To sign up, go to

This course will get you started learning all about real estate. I want to help you quit your job and change your life, so you can live the dream life with passive income.

Here is a music video by Dee-1 who wrote about bad debt in the form of a car note.
You can find him on instagram here:

making money with rental properties

Making Money with Rental Properties FREE Investing Course

Get it FREE and Subscribe to the MPI Newsletter with loads of investing tips, advice, and advanced strategies for investing in real estate.



Get the FREE Real Estate Investing Guide


Related Articles

How to Find Off Market Properties

What Is Equity and How to Make Money From It

How To Invest For A Recession Real Estate Series #1

Get 5X Profits w/ Short Term Rentals Anywhere

Make More Money With The Inflation Crisis 2022

Make Millions by Working On (Not In) Your Business

Get What You Need To Successfully Invest in Real Estate

Get All of the MPI Courses Plus Coaching!


6 Masterclass Courses

Premium online courses for any level of investor: beginner-advanced. Completely go at your own pace and can be taken through “Self-Study” or through “Membership”.


Group Coaching

Fast-track your investing success with access all past students’ work. Get access to the list of places to invest, business contacts, lenders, and resources other students have already found.


Investor Community

Work with MPI Coaches and Students inside the MPI Student Community.


Student Success Program

Pair up with another like-minded student for accountability, and crush your investing goals together.


Real Estate Wealth Builders

Get the coaching, education, community, and resources you need to become a successful real estate investor.